Skip to main content

Sound Advice: July 2, 2025

What is the risk of investing in top-performing mutual funds? And why is recently great performance usually followed by poor performance?

Investing in top-performing mutual funds comes with several risks, and recent strong performance is often followed by weaker results due to well-documented market phenomena.

Risks of Investing in Top-Performing Mutual Funds

  • Mean Reversion: Mutual fund performance tends to revert to the mean over time. Funds that outperform their peers are likely to see their excess returns diminish as the factors or luck that drove their success fade. This means that investing in funds after a period of strong performance may expose you to disappointment as returns normalize. 
  • Herding and Overcrowding: When a fund achieves top performance, it often attracts large inflows from new investors. These inflows can force the fund to buy more of the same assets, potentially driving up prices and reducing future returns. As funds’ assets grow, they are increasingly burdened with the need to limit their investments to the largest companies.  For that reason, there is an increasing likelihood of duplication of holdings.  Indeed, investors who follow the largest funds may discover that 50% or more of the underlying holdings are duplications.  So much for thoughts of diversification.
  • Large funds also face increased trading costs and liquidity constraints, which can hurt performance.
  • Management and Style Changes: Top-performing funds may close to new investors or experience manager turnover, both of which can negatively impact future returns. Manager changes, in particular, have been shown to lead to underperformance, especially if the outgoing manager was skilled.
  • High Fees: Many top-performing funds charge higher fees, which can erode returns over time, especially as performance reverts to the mean.
  • Survivorship and Selection Bias: Only the funds that performed well are highlighted, while underperformers are often closed or merged away, giving a misleading impression of the overall likelihood of success.

Why Great Performance Is Often Followed by Poor Performance

  • Mean Reversion: This is the dominant explanation. Exceptional performance is often the result of a combination of skill and luck. Luck tends to even out over time, and even skilled managers may see their edge disappear as others catch on or market conditions change. Although a new investing wrinkle may prove to be successful temporarily, that edge will vanish as others catch on.
  • Flow-Performance Relationship: Strong recent performance attracts more investor money, which can make it harder for managers to deploy capital effectively, especially if the fund’s strategy is capacity-constrained.
  • Portfolio Imbalances: Funds that have outperformed may end up with portfolios heavily weighted in past winners. If these stocks revert to the mean, the fund’s performance will suffer.
  • Behavioral Biases: Investors and managers alike may overestimate the persistence of good performance, leading to overconfidence and poor decision-making.

In short, top-performing mutual funds are not a guarantee of future success. Investors should be cautious and consider the risks of mean reversion, overcrowding, and other factors that can turn yesterday’s winners into tomorrow’s disappointments.  

In most cases, yesterday’s winners will become tomorrow’s losers. Stick to ultra low cost index funds. They will be the leaders over time.

N. Russell Wayne

Weston, CT  06883

203-895-8877

www.soundasset.blogspot.com

 

 

  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sound Advice: January 3, 2025

2025 Market Forecasts: Stupidity Taken To An Extreme   If you know anything about stock market performance, you can only gag at the nonsense “esteemed forecasters” are now putting forth about the prospective path of stocks in the year ahead.   Our cousins in the UK would call this rubbish.   I would not be as kind. Leading the Ship of Fools is the forecast from the Chief Investment Strategist at Oppenheimer who is looking for a year-end 2025 level for the Standard & Poor’s Index of 7,100, a whopping 21% increase from the most recent standing.   Indeed, most of these folks are looking for double-digit gains.   Only two expect stocks to weaken. In the last 30 years, the market has risen by more than 20% only 15 times.   The exceptional span during that time was 1996-1999, which accounted for four of those jumps.   What followed in 2000 through 2002 was the polar opposite: 2000:      -9.1% 2001:     -11.9% ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: March 10, 2021

The ABCs of Stock Picking After decades of analyzing stocks (and funds) and investing for clients, I'm happy to share in plain English what's involved, what works, and what doesn't.  Keep in mind the reality that successful stock picking is an effort to maintain a good batting average. In baseball, a batting average of .300 or better is considered quite good.  With stock picking, you need to do better than .600, which means you have many more winners than losers. No one gets it right all of the time.  It's not even close.  Wall Street shops all have their recommended lists and the financial media regularly hawk 10 stocks to buy now. Following that road usually is a direct route to disaster.  Don't be tempted. Let's begin with the big picture: The stock market goes up and down over time, but the long-term trend is up.  When there's a rally under way, everyone feels like a genius.  When the market hits an air pocket, though, with few exception...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: June 17, 2020

Rock and a Hard Place Regardless of your age, impressions from childhood linger.  As the first days of summer approach, we all remember the feeling that accompanied the end of a school year.  Yet as much as many of us would like to believe we again have the summertime freedom to do as we wish, the reality is quite the opposite. Although months of confinement and limitations on social interaction have increased our personal discomfort and severely impacted the business community, our current situation is not analogous to the end of any school year.  It’s quite the opposite. There is every reason to continue wearing face masks, social distancing, and avoiding close contact with others.  Nothing suggests that we can modify our behavior significantly or resume patterns of daily living we enjoyed only a few months ago. There are no meaningful advances in medical treatments.  At best, there are attempts to combine different approaches...
Post a Comment
Read more