Sound Advice: November 13, 2024

Medicare Advantage: More, But Usually Not Better

Medicare Advantage plans are marketed as a way to get "more" than Original Medicare (Part A and Part B), but it's important to be cautious about what "more" really means and whether the trade-offs are worth it.

Here’s a breakdown of the key points to consider when it comes to Medicare Advantage plans:

1. "More" Doesn't Always Mean Better

• Additional Benefits: Medicare Advantage plans often come with extra benefits not covered by Original Medicare, such as vision, dental, hearing, and sometimes even gym memberships. These perks sound attractive, but often have limitations or extra costs. For instance, dental and vision coverage may only cover basic services, and you might have to choose from a limited network of providers.
• Medicare Advantage vs. Original Medicare: While you may get "more" in terms of coverage options, these plans often come with restrictions, such as needing referrals for specialist care or using a specific network of doctors and hospitals. This can limit your choices and might not be as flexible as Original Medicare.

2. Potential Trade-Offs in Quality of Care

• Network Restrictions: Medicare Advantage plans are typically "network-based," meaning you must use doctors, specialists, and hospitals within their network for the lowest costs. If you go out-of-network, you may face higher out-of-pocket costs, or the service may not be covered at all.
• Prior Authorization and Care Management: Some Medicare Advantage plans require prior authorization before certain procedures or treatments are covered. This can delay care or result in denials for services that might be needed, impacting the overall quality of care.
• Cost-Shifting: Although many Medicare Advantage plans have low or even $0 premiums, they often come with higher out-of-pocket costs (such as copayments, coinsurance or deductibles) for medical services compared to Original Medicare. This can quickly add up if you require frequent medical care.

3. Quality Control and Oversight

• Star Ratings: Medicare Advantage plans are rated by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) based on a 1- to 5-star system, which reflects the plan's quality and performance. Some MA plans may have high ratings, but others may fall short in areas such as customer service, care coordination, and handling claims. It's crucial to research the star ratings and read reviews from other beneficiaries before enrolling.
• Cost Considerations: Sometimes the "extra" benefits offered by Medicare Advantage plans come at the cost of lower quality care or reduced flexibility in choosing providers. It’s important to assess whether those additional benefits are worth it for your individual health needs.

4. Choosing Between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare

• Original Medicare (Parts A & B): You can pair Original Medicare with a separate Medicare Part D prescription drug plan and supplemental Medigap (Medicare Supplement) coverage. This option gives you more flexibility in choosing providers and usually comes with fewer restrictions on your care. Even so, you may pay higher premiums for Medigap and a Part D plan.
• Medicare Advantage: It might seem like a good deal, but the trade-offs can be significant for some people. If you're healthy and want the extra benefits such as dental or vision coverage, it might be worth considering. But, if you have complex health needs, frequent doctor visits or prefer to have flexibility in choosing providers, you might find that Original Medicare with a supplemental plan is a better choice.

5. Watch Out for the Marketing

• Over-Selling of Benefits: Medicare Advantage plans are aggressively marketed, especially during open enrollment periods. Be aware that the ads you see on TV or in the mail often highlight the benefits and ignore the potential downsides. The "free" perks may come with hidden costs or restrictions that can make them less useful than they appear.
• Plan Comparison: Every plan is different. What might be a great deal for one person may not work for another. It's essential to carefully compare different Medicare Advantage plans in your area, paying close attention to the specifics of coverage, costs, and provider networks.

Conclusion

While Medicare Advantage can provide extra benefits beyond what Original Medicare offers, it’s important to consider whether the "more" you get is actually worth it. In some cases, the limitations in terms of provider access, care flexibility, and potential cost-sharing may outweigh the added perks. Before making a decision, thoroughly review the plan options, costs, and networks, and consider consulting with a Medicare expert to ensure you're making the best choice for your healthcare needs.

N. Russell Wayne

203-895-8877

nrwayne@soundasset.com