Skip to main content

Sound Advice: October 2, 2024

Technical Analysis of Stocks Has No Value 

The effectiveness of technical analysis in stock trading is a subject of considerable debate. While some investors swear by it, others argue that it is of limited or no use. Here’s a rundown of why some critics believe technical analysis is less effective or "useless":

1. Lack of Fundamental Basis:

  • No Consideration of Company Fundamentals: Technical analysis focuses on historical price and volume data rather than the underlying financial health or business prospects of a company. Critics argue that this means it doesn’t account for fundamental factors that drive a company’s long-term performance.

2. Predictive Challenges:

  • Historical Data Limitations: Technical analysis is based on the premise that historical price patterns can predict future movements. Critics point out that past performance is not always indicative of future results, and patterns may not reliably predict future market behavior.

3. Randomness and Market Efficiency:

  • Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH): According to EMH, stock prices already reflect all available information. If markets are efficient, then technical analysis should not provide any advantage, as any patterns or trends would already be priced in.

4. Self-Fulfilling Prophecies:

  • Market Psychology: Some argue that technical analysis may work because a significant number of traders follow similar patterns, making the predictions a self-fulfilling prophecy. If many traders act based on certain technical signals, their collective actions can influence prices. Even so, this is not a robust or consistent basis for long-term success.

5. Subjectivity and Inconsistency:

  • Interpretation Variability: Different technical analysts may interpret the same chart patterns differently, leading to inconsistent and subjective conclusions. This variability can undermine the reliability of technical analysis.

6. Over-Reliance on Patterns:

  • Pattern Recognition Limitations: Technical analysis often relies on recognizing patterns such as head and shoulders, support and resistance levels, or moving averages. Critics argue that these patterns are not always reliable and can be interpreted in multiple ways.

7. Short-Term Focus:

  • Focus on Timing: Technical analysis often emphasizes short-term price movements and market timing, which can be challenging to master consistently. Long-term investing strategies based on fundamental analysis may provide a more stable approach.

8. Potential for Over-Trading:

  • Frequent Trading Risks: Technical analysis can lead to over-trading based on short-term signals, which may increase transaction costs and reduce overall investment returns. 

Despite the fact that there’s even a hefty textbook on the subject of technical analysis by Robert Edwards & John Magee, there have never been any legitimate studies supporting the claims made by the subject’s proponents.  Indeed, much of technical analysis resembles the patterns on old boxes of Whitman’s Sampler chocolates.

N. Russell Wayne

Weston, CT  06883

203-895-8877

www.soundasset.blogspot.com

 

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sound Advice: February 21, 2024

800-000-0000 That’s 800-000-0000 Again, 800-000-0000 That’s the typical closing for the hard sell commercials that are increasingly polluting media airwaves.   These are the commercials for products or services you rarely need or most definitely should avoid. A substantial number are on behalf of groups of attorneys who would have you believe that you and many others may be entitled to cash compensation for having used or being exposed to some evil item or substance some time in the last few decades.   The pitch always includes a comment that there’s no cost to you unless there is a settlement in your favor. Much of this is rubbish, but when the appeal suggests that there’s nothing to lose, why not take a shot.   And, as you would expect, “advisors” are standing by 24/7 to take your call and help get the process in motion.   What kind of advisor would be available at 3 a.m.? One version of this approach pops up every year between October 15 th and Decemb...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: September 21, 2022

The Professional Approach To Stock Selection There are various approaches to stock selection, but the two that predominate are fundamental analysis and technical analysis.  Fundamental analysis is a numbers-based method that evaluates key factors such as income and financial health, including the past, present, and future.  Technical analysis emphasizes movements and formations of stock prices. Fundamental analysis is based on factors that over time have proved to have a meaningful impact on stock price movements.  The optimal picture of corporate profitability is steady growth, both in the past and, prospectively, in the coming years.  Steady growth is rewarded by higher valuations of underlying earning power than those accorded companies with erratic progress. When professionals screen (filter) the data of the broad universe of stocks, they look for companies that move ahead every year, regardless of the prevailing economic conditions.  Although high pas...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: July 26, 2023

Is Day Trading a Good Idea? Day trading can be both exciting and potentially profitable, but it also comes with significant risks and challenges. Whether it's a good idea depends on several factors, including your financial situation, risk tolerance, time commitment, and knowledge of the markets. Here are some considerations to keep in mind: Risk and volatility: Day trading involves buying and selling securities within a short time frame, often within the same day. This exposes you to the inherent volatility and risks of the market. Prices can fluctuate rapidly, and unexpected events can have a significant impact on stock prices, making it challenging to consistently make profits. Time commitment: Day trading requires a substantial time commitment. It involves closely monitoring market movements, conducting research, and executing trades. It can be stressful and demanding, as you need to be actively engaged in the market during t...
Post a Comment
Read more