THINK TWICE ABOUT BETTER BUSINESS BUREAU RATINGS
Although it might be comforting to believe that ratings
from the Better Business Bureau are reliable, people would be best advised to
avoid betting the ranch on same. Indeed,
there are more than a few reasons not to rely solely on those ratings.
Contrary to popular belief, BBB ratings do not measure
how good a business is. Instead, they
are supposed to measure how likely a business is to respond to its customers.
The key factors ostensibly underlying the
ratings are things such as complaint history, type of business, time in
business, transparency of business practices, willingness to uphold BBB
standards, licensing, and advertising. If,
for example, a license is required, but the business is not licensed, the
rating would drop. Similarly, use of the
BBB logo without permission from the BBB is a no-no.
But there’s more and that’s often the key. Although the BBB presents itself as a
nonprofit organization, it still needs money to operate. That’s where accreditation comes in. One of the ways the BBB earns its money is by
charging businesses to be accredited. If
the business is accredited, it can use the BBB’s accreditation logo and
customers may view the company as more trustworthy.
Even so, back in 2015, CNN Money found a sample of
more than 100 businesses that had ratings of A- or higher despite having
serious actions taken against them by government regulators. Some had been ruled flat-out scams and were
shut down, but still kept their high BBB grade.
Some were required to pay multimillion dollar penalties and others were
charged in government lawsuits.
It seems clear that BBB ratings can be questioned for
a number of reasons. These would include
subjectivity, the role of pay to play, and limited information about the
companies. The reality is that the
ratings provided can vary and may not align with what consumers consider important.
Alternatively, one might consider the burgeoning
number of ratings available on social media as well as commercial websites. Here, too, there is a considerable risk, a
significant part of which may be attributed to shill ratings (i.e., those
posted by paid services or friends of the firm). In all cases, the best advice is to read between
the lines and don’t depend on every note, whether praising or damning.
N. Russell Wayne
Weston, CT
Any questions: please contact me at nrwayne@soundasset.com
203-895-8877
Comments
Post a Comment