Skip to main content

Sound Advice: March 20, 2024

Here’s Why No One Beats The Market Index

In Las Vegas, the house always wins.  And on Wall Street, the market always wins. Let me explain.

Although the media tends to focus on the Dow Jones Industrial Average, which includes only 30 of the largest companies, professional investors compare their results with the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index, a far broader contingent.

But there’s a hitch.  The hitch is that the impact of the company shares included in the index is determined by their overall value.  So it turns out that the top five companies (Apple, Alphabet, Google, Microsoft, and Nvidia) represent more than 21% of the value of the S&P 500.  The movements of these five stocks largely determine the overall movement of the index.

Over time, other mega cap stocks with strong performances may become increasingly important as their market capitalization (number of shares times the stock price) grows.  That provides an ongoing infusion of new market strength.  The only way professional money managers can keep up with the S&P is to follow the same replacement cycle.  With the S&P, it’s automatic.

Let’s not forget that actively managed funds have higher fees and trading costs compared to passively managed indexed funds.  Over time, these costs can eat into returns and make it harder for actively managed funds to outperform their benchmark.

Some managers may outperform the market for short periods, but maintaining that level of outperformance over the long term is challenging.  Strategies that have worked well in the past rarely have staying power.

And then there’s the matter of herd behavior, where fund managers may be reluctant to deviate significantly from the benchmark, limiting their ability to make contrarian or unconventional investment decisions.

It gets worse.  Professionals may face pressure to deliver short-term results, which can lead to a focus on quarterly or annual performance rather than a long-term investment horizon.  This short-term focus may hinder their ability to make patient, value-driven investment decisions.

Some active managers do outperform the market over certain periods, but consistently beating the market over the long term is a formidable challenge, one that invariably proves fruitless.

Why try to beat the house when you can be the house by choosing low-cost index funds that passively track the market index.  By doing so, you get broad exposure, minimal fees, and a portfolio that always wins.

 

N. Russell Wayne

Sound Asset Management

Weston, CT

Any questions: please contact me at nrwayne@soundasset.com

203-895-8877

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sound Advice: February 21, 2024

800-000-0000 That’s 800-000-0000 Again, 800-000-0000 That’s the typical closing for the hard sell commercials that are increasingly polluting media airwaves.   These are the commercials for products or services you rarely need or most definitely should avoid. A substantial number are on behalf of groups of attorneys who would have you believe that you and many others may be entitled to cash compensation for having used or being exposed to some evil item or substance some time in the last few decades.   The pitch always includes a comment that there’s no cost to you unless there is a settlement in your favor. Much of this is rubbish, but when the appeal suggests that there’s nothing to lose, why not take a shot.   And, as you would expect, “advisors” are standing by 24/7 to take your call and help get the process in motion.   What kind of advisor would be available at 3 a.m.? One version of this approach pops up every year between October 15 th and Decemb...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: September 21, 2022

The Professional Approach To Stock Selection There are various approaches to stock selection, but the two that predominate are fundamental analysis and technical analysis.  Fundamental analysis is a numbers-based method that evaluates key factors such as income and financial health, including the past, present, and future.  Technical analysis emphasizes movements and formations of stock prices. Fundamental analysis is based on factors that over time have proved to have a meaningful impact on stock price movements.  The optimal picture of corporate profitability is steady growth, both in the past and, prospectively, in the coming years.  Steady growth is rewarded by higher valuations of underlying earning power than those accorded companies with erratic progress. When professionals screen (filter) the data of the broad universe of stocks, they look for companies that move ahead every year, regardless of the prevailing economic conditions.  Although high pas...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Advice: July 26, 2023

Is Day Trading a Good Idea? Day trading can be both exciting and potentially profitable, but it also comes with significant risks and challenges. Whether it's a good idea depends on several factors, including your financial situation, risk tolerance, time commitment, and knowledge of the markets. Here are some considerations to keep in mind: Risk and volatility: Day trading involves buying and selling securities within a short time frame, often within the same day. This exposes you to the inherent volatility and risks of the market. Prices can fluctuate rapidly, and unexpected events can have a significant impact on stock prices, making it challenging to consistently make profits. Time commitment: Day trading requires a substantial time commitment. It involves closely monitoring market movements, conducting research, and executing trades. It can be stressful and demanding, as you need to be actively engaged in the market during t...
Post a Comment
Read more